Catchlight vs Apple Notes.
Apple keeps standard iCloud notes under a key it holds, and new UK users can no longer switch on Advanced Data Protection to stop that. Catchlight holds no key at all, so only you can read your notes, tasks and reminders, and there's no account to make.
Apple Notes is free, fast and already on your iPhone, and for a lot of people that's exactly enough. It stops being enough the day you ask who else can open it. Any government with a warrant can ask Apple for standard iCloud notes. In the UK the government went further, and Apple pulled Advanced Data Protection for new users rather than open it up, so I tend to land on the side of caution.
At a glance
| Catchlight | Apple Notes | |
|---|---|---|
| Account needed | None. Ever. | Your Apple ID |
| End-to-end encrypted | Yes, on device, always | Not by default, only with Advanced Data Protection |
| UK users | Unaffected, always encrypted | New UK users can no longer enable Advanced Data Protection |
| Where data lives | Your device, optional sync via a folder you own | iCloud (Apple can access standard notes) |
| Notes, tasks & reminders | One unified Take, with notifications | Notes with checklists, reminders are a separate app |
| Price | One flat ~£14.99/yr | Free |
| If you decide to stop paying | Takes stay readable and exportable | Nothing to stop, it's free |
| Verify the privacy | Read the source on GitHub | Trust Apple's policy |
| Platforms | iPhone (iOS 18+), more planned | Apple ecosystem |
Apple iCloud encryption details verified July 2026. Aside from individually locked notes, Apple Notes are end-to-end encrypted only with Advanced Data Protection, which new UK users can't enable. Catchlight is pre-launch, its feature set is subject to change before launch.
Is Apple Notes private?
On an iCloud account, your notes are encrypted in transit and on Apple's servers, but Apple holds the keys, so, effectively, no. Apple can get at them, and can be compelled to hand them over. Advanced Data Protection closes that gap by making iCloud end-to-end encrypted, but it's opt-in, and new users in the UK can't turn it on at all.
Catchlight takes the choice off the table. Your Takes are encrypted on your device with a 12-word Privacy phrase only you hold. There's no setting to switch on, no account, and no server of ours for anything to live on. It reads the same in Manchester as it does anywhere else.
We can't read your Takes. Not because we choose not to, because it's impossible. I've answered the blunt version of this in the Journal, can Apple read your notes. Apple's own per-note lock is better than most people expect and still leaves plenty outside it, and how iPhone locks a note walks through both halves.
What about tasks and reminders?
Apple keeps notes and reminders in two different apps. A thought that's half a note and half a reminder has to live in one or the other, or get copied between them.
In Catchlight there's one kind of thing, a Take. Write, and it's a note. Add a checkbox and it's a task. Add a date and it's a reminder that notifies you. You never have to choose upfront, and you never juggle two apps for one thought.
Where Apple Notes is the better choice
Apple Notes is the better choice if you want something free that's already on your iPhone, iPad and Mac, tied deeply into the rest of Apple, and good enough for notes you're not worried about anyone seeing. If your threat model is low and you're happy trusting Apple with your data, it's a genuinely excellent app, and it costs nothing.
Where Catchlight is the better choice
Catchlight is the better choice if you want your notes private by architecture rather than by policy, if you'd rather hold your own key than trust a company with it, if losing Advanced Data Protection in the UK bothered you, and if you'd like a note, a task and a reminder to finally be the same thing, in one safe place.
Common questions
Can Apple really read my notes?
On a standard iCloud account, yes. Apple holds the encryption keys for Notes and can access them, or be compelled to. Only Advanced Data Protection makes them end-to-end encrypted, and that's now unavailable to new UK users. Catchlight is always zero-knowledge, only you hold the key.
Do I need an account for Catchlight, like an Apple ID?
No. Catchlight needs no account, no email and no sign-up. You're given a 12-word Privacy phrase on first launch, and that's your key. An Apple ID password can be reset. Those 12 words can't, by anyone, me included, so they belong on paper somewhere safe.
Does Catchlight do reminders like Apple Reminders?
Yes, but in the same place as your notes. One Take can be a note, a task and a time or location reminder at once, so there's no separate reminders app to keep in step.
All comparisons → · See what Catchlight is → · Questions, answered →